Tax Litigation
Disagreeing with a CRA Reassessment: The First Decisions
A CRA reassessment calls for a clear response: identify the disputed adjustments, preserve the right to object and assess payment separately.
Read the Article →Tax Litigation Lawyer in Toronto
Stellar Law represents individuals and businesses in disputes with the Canada Revenue Agency, from audit enquiries and proposed adjustments to objections and Tax Court appeals. We challenge disputed tax positions through detailed analysis of the law and the financial record, focused submissions and courtroom advocacy. Our advice addresses the tax exposure, the available remedies and the practical cost of pursuing them.
A tax dispute often turns on the gap between the CRA’s interpretation and the evidence of what occurred. Rana Nosratpanah and her team examine the transactions, financial records and legal grounds behind the disputed position. We identify which findings can be challenged, what further evidence is needed and how to present the case to the CRA or the court.
That preparation informs both resolution and litigation. We pursue opportunities to resolve or narrow a dispute where the facts and law support them, and prepare unresolved issues for adjudication. Throughout the matter, we advise on the strength of the case, procedural deadlines and the implications of continuing the dispute, including interest and any collection exposure.
An audit response can influence whether the CRA proposes an adjustment and the basis on which it does so. We review requests for information and proposal letters, identify the transactions and tax years in issue, and prepare responses supported by the relevant records and legal analysis. Where appropriate, we work with the client’s accountant to reconcile the financial evidence and address the CRA’s concerns.
A reassessment may disallow an expense, add income, deny a credit or change the treatment of a transaction. We examine the reasons for each adjustment, the assumptions underlying it and the records that support a challenge. The advice addresses both the merits of the dispute and the steps required to preserve the right to contest it.
An objection presents the taxpayer’s challenge through the CRA’s administrative review process. We prepare the notice of objection and supporting submissions, identify the factual and legal errors alleged, and respond to requests for further information. The aim is to put a substantiated case before the reviewing officer and define any issues that may need to proceed to court.
We represent taxpayers in appeals before the Tax Court of Canada. The work includes framing the issues in the notice of appeal, reviewing the Crown’s response, assembling documentary evidence and preparing witnesses. The procedure and preparation depend on the appeal. Opportunities for resolution are assessed alongside the evidence and arguments required for a hearing.
Income tax disputes may concern whether an amount is income or a capital gain, whether an expense is deductible, whether a credit is available or how a transaction should be treated. We assess the applicable rules against the agreements, accounting records and other evidence. Our submissions explain why the disputed assessment should be changed and how the evidence supports that position.
GST/HST disputes require close attention to the supplies made, the tax charged and the documentation supporting input tax credits. We examine the transactions and business records behind the assessment, identify the disputed treatment and prepare the objection or appeal. Payment and collection must also be addressed: the protections available in an income tax dispute do not apply in the same way to GST/HST.
A challenge to the legal basis of a penalty is different from a request for discretionary relief from penalties or interest. We identify the appropriate route and the evidence needed to support it. Where collection is an immediate concern, we also assess the payment position and available procedural steps. An objection does not always prevent collection, and interest may continue while the dispute is unresolved.
Have the CRA letter, assessment or other decision, its dates and a short account of the issue available. Tell the office about any approaching deadline. We will explain how to provide confidential records after the initial enquiry.
Official information: CRA objections and appeals and Tax Court of Canada proceedings.
Tax Litigation
A CRA reassessment calls for a clear response: identify the disputed adjustments, preserve the right to object and assess payment separately.
Read the Article →Not necessarily. A CRA request for records or a proposed adjustment can raise legal issues before a final assessment. Advice at that stage can help identify what is being requested and how the response should address the disputed issue.
Not always. The result depends on the tax and the stage of the dispute. Income tax and GST/HST do not have identical collection rules, and interest may continue. The objection and the payment position should be considered separately.
No. The correct route depends on the decision. An assessment appeal differs from a review of a discretionary decision, such as taxpayer relief. Identifying the correct procedure and deadline is part of the initial assessment.
Contacting the CRA or discussing payment does not, by itself, extend an objection or appeal deadline.
YOUR NEXT STEP
Have the CRA correspondence and its dates available. We can discuss the disputed issue, the available procedural route and the work required to advance your position.