Establishing the Grounds for an Objection
An income tax reassessment may disallow expenses, add income or impose penalties. The first task is to establish what the Canada Revenue Agency changed, why it made the change and whether its position is supported by the facts and the Income Tax Act. This article concerns income tax reassessments; GST/HST disputes follow a separate statutory process.
The reassessment should be read alongside the filed return, the audit correspondence and the records underlying each adjustment. A disagreement may concern what happened, the legal treatment of a transaction or both. The response must identify the error alleged and explain the treatment the taxpayer says is correct. Challenging the total balance without addressing the adjustments that produced it leaves the central issues unresolved.
A notice of objection must set out the relevant facts and reasons for objecting. Agreements, invoices, bank records and contemporaneous correspondence should be connected to the particular issue they establish. Missing records and inconsistencies need to be addressed, not buried in a large volume of documents. A coherent account of the transactions, supported by the applicable law and evidence, provides the foundation for the objection.
Preserving the Right to Object
For most personal income tax reassessments, an individual other than a trust has until the later of one year after the return’s filing deadline and 90 days after the day the CRA sent the notice to object. The filing deadline means the date the return was due, not the date it was actually filed. Corporations generally have 90 days after the notice was sent. Special assessments and other taxpayer categories require separate consideration; the deadline must be calculated from the actual notice and applicable provisions.
Discussions with the CRA or an outstanding request to adjust a return do not, by themselves, extend the objection deadline. Where a formal objection is needed, it should be filed in time rather than left to depend on an informal review being completed. Keep the notice and proof of submission with the file.
If the deadline has passed, an application to extend time must be made within one year after the original objection deadline, and the statutory conditions must be met. Among them, the taxpayer must show that, during the original objection period, they were unable to act or instruct someone to act, or genuinely intended to object. Granting the application must be just and equitable, and the application must have been made as soon as circumstances permitted. The additional year is a limit for seeking an extension, not an automatic extension of the objection period.
Payment and the Next Stage
A valid objection generally postpones collection action on disputed income tax until 90 days after the CRA sends its decision. That protection has exceptions, including rules affecting large corporations, certain tax-shelter claims and amounts that had to be withheld and remitted. A court may also authorize early collection where delay would jeopardize recovery. Filing an objection should therefore not be treated as a blanket suspension of collection against every tax balance.
Interest generally continues to accrue while an amount remains owing. Payment can reduce further interest while the objection continues. Whether to pay some or all of the disputed amount requires a separate assessment of the available funds and the cost of leaving the balance outstanding. A payment arrangement addresses how a debt will be paid; it does not establish that the reassessment is correct or replace a notice of objection.
If the CRA confirms the assessment or reassesses following the objection, a further challenge may be brought in the Tax Court of Canada. The ordinary appeal deadline is 90 days after the CRA sends that notice. An appeal may also be available once 90 days have elapsed after the objection was served without the required decision being communicated. That does not mean the CRA must decide every objection within 90 days. The appropriate next step depends on the issues, the record and the procedural position.
Stellar Law represents individuals and businesses in CRA disputes and tax litigation. Rana Nosratpanah and her team review the reassessment and audit record, assess the legal grounds for challenge, prepare objections and advise on Tax Court proceedings where necessary. Bring the notice, filed return, audit correspondence and supporting records to the initial discussion, and identify any approaching deadline. The immediate priorities are to preserve the right to challenge the reassessment and establish the evidence needed to do so.
