Leave to appeal granted:
Leave and both cross-appeal applications granted. Filing timetable set October 28, 2026; hearing date not yet confirmed.
Article published:

The Case Before the Court

On October 22, 2026, the Supreme Court granted the federal government permission to appeal. It also permitted cross-appeals by the Canadian Civil Liberties Association and the Canadian Constitution Foundation. The decision allows the litigation to proceed; it does not overturn the judgment under appeal. A hearing date has not yet been confirmed.

What the Lower Courts Decided

The federal government invoked the Emergencies Act on February 14, 2022. The resulting measures restricted certain public assemblies and required financial institutions to freeze designated persons’ accounts.

The Federal Court found that the invocation was unreasonable and exceeded the authority granted by the Act. On January 16, 2026, the Federal Court of Appeal upheld that conclusion. It also upheld findings that the assembly restrictions infringed freedom of expression and that the Economic Order’s information-sharing provisions infringed the right to be secure against unreasonable search or seizure. Those infringements were not justified under section 1 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

The Court drew an important distinction between freezing accounts and sharing financial information. It held that the account-freezing provision did not itself authorize searches or seizures for Charter purposes. The section 8 infringement concerned the collection and sharing of private financial information.

The Limits of Emergency Powers

Parliament imposed specific conditions on the use of the Act. The Federal Court of Appeal concluded that the government had not demonstrated reasonable grounds to believe that a national emergency or threat to national security existed within the statutory definitions, or that existing laws were inadequate.

The distinction matters. Serious disruption does not, by itself, establish that the legal threshold for emergency powers has been met. The justification must address the conditions Parliament prescribed and the evidence available when the government acted.

Why the Appeal Matters

The appeal’s broader significance lies in how courts assess government decisions made under pressure. Urgency may explain why a decision was made. Judicial review examines whether the decision was legally justified.

The Supreme Court’s reasons could clarify the evidence and justification required to invoke emergency powers, as well as the scrutiny applied to measures affecting constitutional rights. That guidance would matter both to future governments considering extraordinary action and to those whose rights are affected.