The Grounds for Detention
The accused remains presumed innocent. Detention before trial must be justified on a recognized legal ground: ensuring attendance in court, protecting public safety or maintaining confidence in the administration of justice. The last ground requires consideration of all the circumstances, including the apparent strength of the prosecution’s case, the gravity and circumstances of the alleged offence, the potential sentence and outstanding charges arising from separate events.
The Crown Attorney ordinarily bears the burden of establishing why detention is justified. Where a reverse onus applies, the accused must demonstrate why detention is not justified by showing how the proposed release plan addresses the relevant risks. Identifying the applicable burden and the grounds in issue is therefore essential to preparing the hearing.
Counsel must assess the allegations against the available bail material and the accused person’s circumstances. Prior compliance with court orders, outstanding charges and the proposed living arrangements may require particular attention. The release proposal should answer the concerns raised by that record, with evidence capable of supporting the arrangements on which the court is being asked to rely.
A Release Proposal Supported by Evidence
Each proposed arrangement should serve an identifiable purpose. A residence must be available and compatible with any proposed contact restrictions. Supervision must be practical for the person undertaking it. Employment, caregiving and treatment arrangements may affect both the proposal and the accused person’s ability to comply with it.
Where a surety is proposed, counsel must examine that person’s relationship with the accused, availability, criminal history and financial circumstances. The surety must understand the supervision required, the obligation to report breaches to police and the financial amount at risk. Those responsibilities require an assessment of the person’s actual capacity to fulfil them.
Neither a surety nor a cash deposit is required in every case. The form of release must be assessed under the applicable bail provisions, with attention to less onerous arrangements that can address the identified concerns. An available bail supervision program may be relevant. Adding restrictions without examining their necessity can leave the accused with obligations that do little to address the reasons release is opposed.
The Terms of Release Matter
Release conditions must be considered as carefully as the decision to seek release. They should address the relevant risks and account for the accused person’s ability to comply. A curfew may conflict with night-shift employment; a geographical restriction may prevent access to necessary treatment. Foreseeable conflicts and any appropriate exceptions should be addressed in the proposed wording.
Agreement with the Crown Attorney can resolve or narrow contested issues, but the court determines whether release is justified and on what terms. Once imposed, conditions cannot simply be set aside by a private agreement. A change must be made through the proper legal process.
Rana Nosratpanah and her team review the bail material, assess the grounds advanced for detention, prepare proposed sureties and develop the evidence and terms supporting release. Where release or particular conditions remain contested, they present the legal and factual basis for the order sought.
For an urgent bail hearing, call Stellar Law at 416.821.2529. Evening and weekend calls are answered or promptly returned.
Rana’s Commentary
This related reel addresses the deposit requirement introduced in August 2026. Read the cash-bail article below for the subsequent injunction and the distinction between a pledge and a deposit.
Sources
- Criminal Code, section 493.1: restraint and reasonable conditions ↗
- Criminal Code, section 515: release and detention ↗
- R. v. Zora, 2020 SCC 14: necessary and proportionate bail conditions ↗
- Ontario Court of Justice: Practice Direction Regarding Bail Hearings ↗
- Legal Aid Ontario: bail hearings ↗
- Legal Aid Ontario: responsibilities of a surety ↗
This article provides general information, not legal advice. Advice depends on the facts and circumstances of your case.
