1086289 Ontario Inc. (Urban Electrical Contractors) v. Welland (City), 2026 ONCA 352
Court of Appeal for Ontario
Decision:

The Rule the Court Rejected

In 1086289 Ontario Inc. (Urban Electrical Contractors) v. Welland (City), a five-judge panel considered four appeals concerning undisclosed or late-disclosed partial settlements. The existing rule, associated with Handley Estate, treated a failure to disclose immediately an agreement that changed the adversarial landscape as an abuse of process. A stay of proceedings followed automatically, without a separate assessment of prejudice or whether a lesser remedy would suffice.

The Court unanimously overruled that rule. It held that the automatic finding of abuse and mandatory stay were inconsistent with the contextual and discretionary nature of the abuse-of-process doctrine. Non-disclosure must instead be assessed in light of the particular circumstances, including its nature, timing, effect on the litigation and any harm to parties or the administration of justice.

Disclosure and the Appropriate Remedy

The Court distinguished two questions: whether the conduct amounts to an abuse of process, and what remedy an established abuse requires. Prejudice to another party is relevant, but it is not a prerequisite to a finding of abuse. Conduct that undermines the integrity of the judicial process can itself justify intervention. The remedy must be proportionate. A stay remains available only in the clearest cases, where no lesser remedy would adequately address the harm to a party or the judicial process.

The judgment also addressed rule 49.14 of the Rules of Civil Procedure, which came into force on June 16, 2025. The Court explained that the rule clarifies partial-settlement disclosure obligations and permits a range of remedies. Breach of the rule does not itself compel a finding of abuse of process or a particular remedy. The disclosure obligation remains; the automatic consequence does not.

The Four Appeals

In Welland, the litigation concerned the design and construction of a sporting facility. The motion judge had refused a stay without deciding whether the non-disclosure caused prejudice or whether a lesser remedy was appropriate. The Court allowed the appeal and returned the motion for a fresh hearing under the revised approach. It did not itself impose a stay.

In Evertz, disclosure of a settlement had been delayed and incomplete, and the plaintiff had repeatedly misled both another party and the court about its scope. The Court held that the misleading conduct, unnecessary litigation and unacceptable delay justified a finding of abuse. A lesser remedy would not suffice. The stay was upheld and the appeal dismissed.

In Howran, the non-settling party already knew the essential terms of the proposed arrangement and had received updates during negotiations. Although disclosure of the final agreement was late, the Court found no abuse of process on the circumstances before it. It dismissed the appeal and upheld the refusal of a stay.

In Thrive, the finding of abuse of process remained, but the motion judge had treated a stay as mandatory. The Court allowed the appeal, set aside the stay and returned the matter for the judge to determine the appropriate remedy. The remittal concerned the remedy, not a fresh determination of whether there had been an abuse.

Appeal Routes

The Court also clarified that the route of appeal depends on the legal nature of the order. An order granting a stay is final and appealable to the Court of Appeal. Orders imposing a remedy short of a stay, or refusing a stay in this context, are generally interlocutory and appealable to the Divisional Court with leave.