The Case Before the Court
The Supreme Court of Canada heard Atlantic Lottery Corporation, et al. v. Attorney General of Ontario on October 7, 2026. Judgment remains reserved. The appeal concerns a proposed expansion of Ontario’s regulated online gaming and sports betting system to allow participation with players outside Canada.
What Ontario Proposes
Ontario’s proposal would connect players in the province with players abroad through shared games and betting pools. In its written submissions, Ontario explains that players here would continue to use sites within the iGaming Ontario system, while players abroad would use sites operating in their own jurisdictions.
Ontario’s position is that iGaming Ontario would retain control over the Ontario side of the arrangement, including wagers, payouts and player data. Foreign sites would remain subject to the laws of their own jurisdictions. Players elsewhere in Canada would remain excluded unless their province entered into an agreement with Ontario. These are features of the proposed model, whose legality is before the Court.
The Legal Question
Section 207(1)(a) of the Criminal Code permits a provincial government to conduct and manage a lottery scheme “in that province” in accordance with provincial law. It also expressly permits arrangements with another provincial government. The provision creates an exception to the Code’s gambling prohibitions.
The appeal turns on the territorial limits of that exception. Can Ontario connect its scheme to games and betting involving players abroad while continuing to conduct and manage a lottery scheme within the province? The answer depends on how the statutory words apply to the proposed arrangement.
What the Court of Appeal Decided
On November 12, 2025, a majority of the Court of Appeal for Ontario concluded in Reference re iGaming Ontario, 2025 ONCA 770, that the proposed model would remain lawful under the Criminal Code. Justice van Rensburg dissented, concluding that Ontario’s involvement in the international aspects of the model would fall outside the statutory exception.
The disagreement concerns how Parliament’s territorial restriction applies to the proposed system. The Supreme Court must now resolve that issue. Its decision has not yet been released.
Why the Appeal Matters
For online gaming operators, the judgment could determine whether Ontario’s regulated market can connect to international pools of players on the proposed terms. It could also clarify how provincial control is assessed when games, participants and commercial operations extend across borders.
The wider commercial significance lies in the relationship between a business model and the authority to operate it. A regulated business expanding across jurisdictions must account for who conducts the activity, where participants are located and which laws govern each part of the arrangement. Those questions shape the structure of the business and the agreements supporting it.
